| Geometry |
Qualification Small, feature-dense metal geometry or a clear opportunity to consolidate machined or assembled features. |
Review Large simple form, abrupt thick-to-thin transitions, unsupported thin features, or local mass likely to affect distortion. |
2D drawing, 3D CAD, overall dimensions, wall sections, undercuts, functional features, and preferred parting or gate restrictions. |
| Cosmetic Surfaces |
Qualification Visible, hidden, and post-finished zones are separated before tooling. |
Review Appearance requirements are defined only after samples, or all surfaces are treated as equally cosmetic-critical. |
Surface-zone map, finish specification, texture or appearance reference, edge requirements, and protected areas. |
| Assembly Interfaces |
Qualification Critical datums, mating features, motion interfaces, and assembly priorities are identified. |
Review Every dimension is treated as critical, or mating-part information is unavailable. |
Critical-dimension list, datum scheme, mating-part data, fit or movement requirement, and inspection method. |
| Material and Finish |
Qualification The alloy direction is reviewed together with corrosion, wear, appearance, and post-finish needs. |
Review A grade is named without functional requirements, or polishing, plating, coating, or PVD is added late. |
Material target, performance priorities, finish route, coating or plating specification, and restricted surface zones. |
| Product Lifecycle and Volume |
Qualification Stable repeat demand or a component family can support tooling and process development. |
Review The product cycle is short or uncertain, the quantity is low, or the comparison only considers prototype piece price. |
Annual volume, expected program life, ramp schedule, forecast range, and current manufacturing route. |
| Inspection and Acceptance |
Qualification Dimensional, functional, cosmetic, and post-finish acceptance criteria are defined before first samples. |
Review Acceptance depends on subjective sample review without agreed datums, visual zones, or measurement conditions. |
Inspection plan, critical characteristics, cosmetic acceptance criteria, gauges or test method, and packaging or handling requirements. |